Ethical Governance Framework

PUBLICATION ETHICS AND RESEARCH INTEGRITY

Upholding ethical accountability, editorial integrity, transparency, and responsible scholarly publishing.

The International Journal of Research on Multidisciplinary Studies (IJROMS) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics, research integrity, and responsible scholarly communication. The journal recognizes that the credibility of academic publishing depends on the collective responsibility of authors, editors, peer reviewers, and the publisher to uphold principles of honesty, fairness, transparency, accountability, and professional conduct throughout the research publication process.

IJROMS adopts the ethical principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) as an important reference in developing and implementing its editorial and publication practices. These principles guide the journal in preventing publication misconduct, addressing ethical concerns, protecting the integrity of the scholarly record, and ensuring that editorial decisions are made through fair, impartial, and academically defensible processes.

1. Fundamental Principles of Ethical Governance

The ethical governance of IJROMS is founded on the following principles, which guide the conduct and responsibilities of all individuals participating in the journal's publication activities:

Integrity and Honesty. All research and publication activities must be conducted truthfully, with accurate representation of research methods, findings, data, sources, and contributions.

Fairness and Impartiality. Manuscripts must be evaluated objectively on their scholarly merit, relevance, methodological rigor, originality, and contribution to knowledge, without discrimination or inappropriate influence.

Transparency and Accountability. Editorial decisions, publication procedures, and the handling of ethical concerns must be guided by clear processes and appropriate documentation.

Confidentiality and Respect. Unpublished manuscripts, research data, personal information, and communications must be handled responsibly and disclosed only when ethically and procedurally justified.

Protection of the Scholarly Record. The journal must take appropriate measures to address errors, questionable research practices, and confirmed ethical violations that may compromise the reliability of published scholarship.

2. Ethical Responsibilities of Publication Stakeholders

Ethical scholarly publishing requires coordinated compliance with established responsibilities among all publication stakeholders. IJROMS expects each party to observe the following obligations:

A. Authors

  • Submit original scholarly work that has not been published previously or submitted simultaneously to another journal.
  • Ensure that all information, data, results, and references are accurate, properly documented, and honestly represented.
  • Provide appropriate acknowledgment and citation of the intellectual contributions of other researchers.
  • Ensure that authorship accurately reflects substantial scholarly contributions and that all listed authors approve the submitted manuscript.
  • Disclose relevant conflicts of interest, funding sources, and applicable ethical approvals or permissions.
  • Cooperate with editorial inquiries and provide clarifications, supporting documentation, or corrections when reasonably required.

B. Editors

  • Evaluate submissions objectively and make editorial decisions based on scholarly quality, originality, relevance, and compliance with journal policies.
  • Maintain editorial independence and avoid inappropriate personal, institutional, commercial, or external influence.
  • Protect the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and all related editorial communications.
  • Identify and appropriately manage potential conflicts of interest.
  • Ensure that peer review is conducted fairly, consistently, and in accordance with the journal's double-blind review process.
  • Respond responsibly to allegations of misconduct and initiate appropriate procedures when ethical concerns arise.

C. Peer Reviewers

  • Provide independent, objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments of assigned manuscripts.
  • Maintain strict confidentiality and refrain from unauthorized use or disclosure of unpublished research content.
  • Declare potential conflicts of interest and decline assignments when impartiality may reasonably be compromised.
  • Identify relevant uncited literature, methodological concerns, inconsistencies, and potential ethical issues.
  • Complete reviews within agreed timelines and communicate professionally with the editorial office.
  • Observe the journal's policies concerning the responsible and confidential use of artificial intelligence in peer review.

D. Publisher

  • Support the journal's commitment to ethical publishing, transparency, and the preservation of scholarly integrity.
  • Provide appropriate administrative and operational support for responsible journal management.
  • Respect editorial independence and refrain from improperly influencing manuscript evaluation, peer review, or publication decisions.
  • Cooperate with the editorial leadership in addressing substantiated ethical concerns and maintaining the integrity of the published scholarly record.

3. Prevention and Identification of Publication Misconduct

IJROMS recognizes that publication misconduct can undermine academic credibility, distort the scholarly record, and weaken public confidence in research. The journal therefore maintains procedures for identifying, evaluating, and addressing suspected violations of publication ethics.

The journal's ethical oversight covers, but is not limited to, the following forms of misconduct and questionable publication practices:

  • Plagiarism: Presenting another person's ideas, words, data, or intellectual contributions as one's own without appropriate acknowledgment.
  • Data Fabrication: Inventing research data, observations, results, or experimental records that do not exist.
  • Data Falsification: Manipulating, altering, or selectively presenting research materials, procedures, data, or findings in a misleading manner.
  • Duplicate or Redundant Publication: Submitting or publishing substantially overlapping work without appropriate disclosure and editorial consideration.
  • Simultaneous Submission: Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal at the same time.
  • Authorship Misconduct: Inappropriate attribution, omission of qualified contributors, unauthorized authorship changes, or disputes involving the accuracy of authorship declarations.
  • Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest: Failure to disclose relationships or circumstances that could improperly influence research, review, or editorial judgment.
  • Citation Manipulation: Inappropriate citation practices intended to artificially increase citation counts or influence scholarly metrics.
  • Research Ethics Violations: Failure to observe applicable ethical requirements involving human participants, animals, informed consent, privacy, or institutional approval.
  • Peer Review Misconduct: Breaches of reviewer confidentiality, manipulation of the review process, impersonation, or other practices that compromise independent evaluation.

4. Manuscript Screening and Ethical Compliance

All manuscripts submitted to IJROMS undergo an initial editorial and technical assessment before they may proceed to peer review. This process is intended to determine whether submissions comply with the journal's requirements for originality, completeness, research ethics, academic presentation, and publication standards.

Depending on the nature and requirements of the submission, the screening process may include:

  • Assessment of manuscript originality and potential textual overlap using available similarity-detection procedures.
  • Verification of authorship information, institutional affiliations, acknowledgments, and declarations.
  • Examination of research ethics statements, informed consent declarations, and relevant institutional approvals, where applicable.
  • Review of funding disclosures and declarations of potential conflicts of interest.
  • Preliminary assessment of research methodology, data presentation, citations, and reference documentation.
  • Identification of possible duplicate submissions, redundant publications, or other concerns requiring clarification.

Important: Similarity reports and automated screening results are assessment tools and should not, by themselves, be treated as conclusive proof of plagiarism or research misconduct. Editorial judgment and examination of the relevant context remain essential.

5. Conflict of Interest Management

IJROMS requires authors, editors, and peer reviewers to disclose actual, potential, or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest that may affect the objectivity, credibility, or impartiality of the publication process.

Conflicts may arise from financial relationships, professional affiliations, personal relationships, academic competition, institutional responsibilities, or other circumstances that could influence scholarly judgment. Disclosed conflicts must be assessed and managed appropriately. Where necessary, an editor or reviewer with a relevant conflict may be excluded from the evaluation or decision-making process to protect the fairness and independence of the proceedings.

6. Handling Allegations and Investigations of Ethical Violations

IJROMS takes allegations of research or publication misconduct seriously. Reports may originate from authors, reviewers, editors, readers, institutions, or other individuals with relevant information. All concerns must be assessed carefully, fairly, confidentially, and without presuming misconduct before the available information has been evaluated.

Depending on the nature and seriousness of the concern, the journal may apply the following general procedure:

Stage 1 – Receipt and Initial Assessment

The editorial office receives and documents the allegation, examines the available information, and determines whether the concern falls within the journal's ethical responsibilities.

Stage 2 – Preliminary Examination

The editorial team evaluates the relevant manuscript, publication record, supporting documents, and other available evidence to determine whether further inquiry is warranted.

Stage 3 – Request for Explanation

Where appropriate, the individuals concerned may be contacted and given a reasonable opportunity to provide explanations, clarifications, or relevant supporting documentation.

Stage 4 – Evaluation and Determination

The editorial leadership evaluates the information objectively and determines the appropriate action based on the nature, seriousness, and available evidence concerning the alleged violation.

Stage 5 – Appropriate Action and Documentation

The journal implements an appropriate response, communicates the outcome to relevant parties when warranted, and maintains records of the matter in accordance with applicable confidentiality and record-management requirements.

When the circumstances warrant institutional involvement, IJROMS may refer the matter to the relevant research institution or other appropriate authority. The journal's inquiry does not replace the formal investigative authority of institutions responsible for determining research misconduct.

7. Corrections, Retractions, and Editorial Notices

IJROMS is committed to preserving the accuracy and reliability of its published scholarly record. When errors, inaccuracies, or ethical concerns are identified after publication, the journal evaluates the matter and determines the appropriate corrective action in accordance with the seriousness and implications of the issue.

Depending on the circumstances, editorial action may include:

  • Correction: Issuance of a correction notice when an identified error requires amendment but does not invalidate the overall findings or integrity of the publication.
  • Retraction: Retraction of an article when substantial concerns undermine the reliability, validity, or ethical acceptability of the published work.
  • Editorial Expression of Concern: Publication of an appropriate notice when a significant concern has arisen but the available information is insufficient for an immediate final determination.
  • Institutional Notification: Communication with relevant institutions or authorities when the circumstances reasonably warrant further investigation or formal action.

Editorial actions must be proportionate to the circumstances, appropriately documented, and communicated transparently while respecting confidentiality, due process, and the rights of the individuals concerned.

8. Confidentiality, Data Protection, and Responsible Communication

IJROMS recognizes the importance of protecting confidential information throughout manuscript submission, peer review, editorial evaluation, publication, and post-publication procedures. Unpublished manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, research data, and personal information must be handled responsibly and accessed only by individuals with legitimate editorial or administrative responsibilities.

Information obtained through the editorial process must not be used for personal advantage, unauthorized dissemination, or purposes unrelated to legitimate journal operations. Any disclosure required by an ethical investigation or applicable institutional or legal obligation must be handled with appropriate care and documentation.

9. Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence

IJROMS recognizes the growing use of artificial intelligence and automated technologies in academic research and scholarly publishing. Their use must remain consistent with principles of transparency, accountability, confidentiality, and research integrity.

Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and scholarly validity of their submissions, including any material developed with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools. The use of such tools must not result in fabricated references, misleading research claims, manipulated findings, or misrepresentation of authorship and intellectual contributions.

Editors and reviewers must observe the journal's applicable AI-use requirements, particularly the protection of confidential manuscript content and the independence of scholarly evaluation. Artificial intelligence must not replace the professional judgment and accountability required in editorial decision-making and peer review.

10. Accountability, Continuous Improvement, and Policy Implementation

The implementation of this Ethical Governance Framework is an ongoing institutional and editorial responsibility. IJROMS seeks to maintain ethical awareness, consistency in editorial practice, and accountability across all stages of the publication process.

The journal may periodically review its ethical policies and procedures to address emerging challenges in scholarly communication, evolving publication standards, and developments in research integrity. Revisions may be introduced when necessary to strengthen transparency, procedural fairness, and the protection of the scholarly record.

All publication stakeholders are expected to familiarize themselves with the journal's applicable policies and cooperate in maintaining an ethical, respectful, and academically responsible publishing environment.